Abstract
Conventional definitions of the achievement gap stop at differences in test scores. Read through Critical Race Theory, the gap is better described as an educational debt: inequities built into the teaching environment itself. This study examines whether anti-racist, equity-centered professional development can change the perceptions and practices of educators and staff. Using a qualitative case study of one Wisconsin district’s year-long training, and Guskey’s (2002) model of teacher change as a lens, I find that beliefs moved while practice largely did not. The barriers were structural. The district skipped the pre-work, left the staff most affected out of planning, and never completed the professional development cycle. I close with concrete moves for leaders that apply to any large rollout.
01Why this matters now
Every district is rolling something out. An equity initiative, a new curriculum, a coaching model, and now AI. The launch day is easy to fund and easy to photograph. The hard part comes after, when a teacher closes the door and decides whether anything about Tuesday will be different.
I have sat on both sides of that door, as a teacher who sat through trainings that were never finished and as a principal responsible for making them stick. This study looks closely at one district that tried to do the right thing for every employee, and asks a question leaders rarely measure: did it change practice?
02From gap to debt
The achievement gap is usually reported as a difference in test scores between groups of students. That framing quietly locates the problem in students. Following Ladson-Billings (2006), I treat it as an educational debt: what a system owes students when its history, its hiring and its teaching have not been built for them.
If the debt lives in the teaching environment, then the adults are where repayment starts. That makes professional development one of the most important levers a district has, and one of the most often wasted.
03The study
The setting was a predominantly White Wisconsin school district, given the pseudonym Maple Wood ISD, where about four of every five staff members identified as White. Responding to disproportionality in special education and achievement gaps between Black and White students, the district held a year-long, districtwide racial equity training in 2019–20 for every employee: teachers, counselors, psychologists, custodians, clerical staff and education assistants. About 420 educators took part.
The training moved through four phases: what equity looks like to you, your school and your community; incarceration data for the county and the state; the unconscious mind of history and oppression; and stereotype threat, cognitive dissonance and how to challenge racial bias at work. Small-group conversations followed each day. COVID-19 ended the cycle before the final sessions.
Does anti-racist, equity-centered professional development change the perceptions and practices of educators and staff to support learning outcomes for traditionally marginalized students?
- To what extent is the content of the training truly anti-racist?
- What impact does it have on educator and staff dispositions?
- How do educators respond, and does that response change their practice toward student learning?
04Findings
The content was anti-racist by design.
Reviewing the materials, I found that the facilitators had built training that would have been anti-racist had it been completed. Participants praised the presenters and described learning a history of their own county they had never been taught. A special education teacher called the material on redlining and home ownership “eye opening.”
Beliefs moved.
Perspective was the most frequent theme in the written responses, ahead of equity and transfer of knowledge. Staff described seeing their own Whiteness, privilege and bias, and a new comfort talking about race. For many non-certified staff it was the first professional development they had ever been invited to.
“How interconnected we are.”
Custodian, describing the training
Practice barely moved.
Only a few educators could name a specific change they would make. Some certified staff planned more culturally relevant books and curriculum. The clearest example came from an administrative assistant, who said she used to brush off students who reported feeling targeted because of their race. She now saw that the student did not need to change to fit the environment. The environment needed to change to fit the student. Overall, the training stayed surface level, low risk and informative.
The barriers were structural.
The district moved fast and skipped the pre-work. Early planning included only senior leadership from teaching and learning. Non-certified staff, who represent most of the district’s employees of color, were not at the table. Small-group discussions were led entirely by White staff. Expectations for non-certified staff were never made clear, so accountability varied. Then the pandemic stopped the cycle, and the urgency did not return.
05Where the cycle stopped
Guskey’s model holds that teacher beliefs change most durably after teachers see new practice work for students. Professional development leads to a change in classroom practice, which leads to a change in student outcomes, which then changes beliefs. Maple Wood addressed the first and last steps. The two in the middle, where students actually feel the difference, were never reached.
Shared language and goals. Where most initiatives stop.
New moves tried in real classrooms, with support close by.
Everyday habit, visible in instruction and in student outcomes.
“It is the transfer of understanding and the transition from talking to doing to practicing that truly results in districts being anti-racist.”
From the conclusion
06Five moves for leaders
Maple Wood did not fail for lack of good intentions, outside experts or tools. It had all three. What it lacked were the structures that carry intention into practice. These are the moves I recommend, drawn from the findings.
Do the pre-work before the launch.
Invite the people a decision will affect into the planning, especially the groups the initiative is meant to serve. Missing voices at the start become missing buy-in at the end.
Check who is at the table, every time.
Before reviewing any data that will shape professional development, run a simple self-monitoring checklist.
Hire and keep people on the same standard.
Use one set of competencies for hiring and for evaluation, and extend it to every employee group, not only certified staff.
Finish the cycle, with accountability.
Plan the training as a multi-year cycle tied to the district’s own student data, set clear expectations for every role, and follow it into classrooms.
Develop the leadership team first.
Principals and central office leaders set the pace. They need their own development before they can carry the work to their staff.
- Is a person of color invited to, and present in, this meeting?
- Are voices represented equally by gender, age, department, race and certification level, and are all of them heard?
- If we cannot reach equal representation, what steps are we taking to consult an outside partner so the work serves our marginalized communities?
The district’s hiring consultant introduced five competencies for certified hires. I recommend extending them to all staff and building them into evaluation, so the standard for joining is the standard for staying:
The same test works for an AI rollout.
Replace “equity training” with “AI tool” and the study reads like a warning about this year’s adoptions. Before a district scales any new tool, I would ask four questions.
- Who planned this? Were teachers, families and the students at the edges part of the decision?
- What will change on Tuesday? Name the classroom practice, not only the feature.
- How will we know it works, and for which students? Decide the evidence before the licenses go out.
- Who finishes the cycle? Name the person accountable for year two and year three.
07Limits and next questions
This is one district, a small interview sample, and a training cut short by a pandemic. I cannot say whether finishing the cycle would have produced an anti-racist district, or how the change in beliefs affected student learning. Future work should study the relationship between anti-racist professional development and teacher disposition over time, through a longitudinal qualitative design that follows the same educators across years.
08Conclusion
Maple Wood had the potential to do something profound for its students, families and staff. It brought every employee into the room and gave them a shared language. What it did not do was pause to ask who was missing from the table, or stay long enough to see belief become practice.
Simply talking about racial equity does not make a district equitable. Leaders who want different outcomes have to plan for the whole journey: the pre-work before the launch, the support in the classroom, and the evidence that it reached the students it was meant for.
“To every Black girl who does not see themself as a scholar in academia, this dissertation is for you!”
From the dedicationCite this work
Final oral committee: Anjalé Welton (Chair), Julie Mead, Carl Grant and Kevin Henry, UW–Madison. Defended May 23, 2022.
